This page contains promotions (affiliate links) (Editorial & ad policy)
Yudanaka and Shibu Onsen Under ¥40,000 for Two: 5 Inns With Meals
Approximate, at the rate on 2026-10-02. You pay in yen.
If you can’t decide, Masaki Ryokan — five rooms on Shibu’s stone-paved street, about ¥12,000 each on a weekday with both meals.
- Cheap Yudanaka onsen: five small inns where two can pay under ¥40,000 with meals
- For the most reviews, Tamakyu; for a bath to yourselves, Yamazakiya
- For top-scoring food, Fujiya; for a Shinshu beef dinner, Andaikan
The five
| Best for | Where to book | Score | Weeknight (per person) | Saturday |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Five rooms on Shibu’s stone-paved street — if you can’t decide | Shibu Onsen Masaki Ryokan Check price |
89/100 | ¥12,000 | — |
| Nine rooms, 628 reviews averaging 4.78 | Shibu Onsen Tamakyu Ryokan Check price |
80/100 | ¥17,000 | — |
| Every booking gets a timed private bath | Yudanaka Onsen Yamazakiya Ryokan Check price |
77/100 | ¥14,000 | ¥14,000–15,000 |
| Five rooms, the top food scores of the seven | Aji no Yado Fujiya Ryokan Check price |
75/100 | ¥16,000 | ¥16,000 |
| Eight rooms, known for its Shinshu beef steak plan | Yudanaka Onsen Andaikan Check price |
63/100 | ¥18,000 | ¥20,000–21,000 |
Prices are the cheapest per person found on Rakuten Travel for Wednesdays and Saturdays between 2026-11-14 – 2027-01-06, for 2 adults in one room (checked 2026-11-06). They move daily — the link shows live prices.
The booking links go to Agoda, which shows today’s price and lets you pay in your own currency. Its price can differ from the Rakuten Travel figures above.
Five rooms on Shibu’s stone-paved street
Reviews: Rakuten Travel 4.60/5 (96)
- Check-in from 14:00, last check-in 19:00
- Free coffee at breakfast
- Takes Rakuten Pay, Rakuten Edy and PayPay
Why it made the five
- On the stone-paved street of the Shibu hot spring town.
- Rakuten’s dinner and breakfast scores are both 4.92.
- The bath is a natural hot spring family bath.
Getting there: About 10 minutes by bus from Yudanaka station on the Nagano Electric Railway. Five free parking spaces, booking needed.
Language and payment: Rakuten lists a few staff with a little English. Visa, Mastercard, JCB, American Express and other cards are listed. Tattoo rules are not published, so ask when you book.
-
Right for: Two people who want to stay in the Shibu town and eat in private.
-
Not for: With five rooms, few dates had a two-meal plan on sale, so book early.
-
Worth knowing: We found a two-meal plan on only one weekday in our search window, and none on a Saturday.
Score breakdown — 89/100
| Criterion | Stars | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Quality | ★★★★☆ | Room, bath and dinner average 4.70 on Rakuten Travel |
| Value for money | ★★★★★ | ¥12,000 per person on a weeknight (Rakuten, dinner and breakfast) — 73% of the median of everything we compared |
| Easy to stay | ★★★★★ | Dinner and breakfast in your room or a private room, about 10 minutes by bus from Yudanaka station, a natural hot spring family bath, a few staff with a little English, and five free parking spaces. |
| Trust | ★★★★☆ | 4.6 across 96 reviews (Rakuten Travel 96) |
| Only here | ★★★★☆ | A five-room inn on Shibu’s stone-paved street, with Rakuten’s dinner and breakfast scores both at 4.92. |
Nine rooms, 628 reviews averaging 4.78
Reviews: Rakuten Travel 4.78/5 (628)
- Dinner and breakfast in a private room or hall
- Last check-in 21:00
- Free morning coffee
Why it made the five
- Rakuten’s 628 reviews average 4.78, the most reviews of the seven.
- Dinner and breakfast both score 4.84.
- A large natural hot spring bath.
Getting there: About 20 minutes by car from Shinshu-Nakano IC. Rakuten gives driving directions only, so ask about the way from Yudanaka station when you book.
Language and payment: Rakuten lists no language support. Visa, Mastercard, JCB, American Express and other cards are listed. Tattoo rules are not published, so ask when you book.
-
Right for: Two people who want to choose on the weight of reviews.
-
Not for: Rakuten gives no route by train, so travellers without a car must check how to get there.
-
Worth knowing: We found a two-meal plan on only two weekdays in our search window, and none on a Saturday.
Score breakdown — 80/100
| Criterion | Stars | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Quality | ★★★★☆ | Room, bath and dinner average 4.69 on Rakuten Travel |
| Value for money | ★★★☆☆ | ¥17,000 per person on a weeknight (Rakuten, dinner and breakfast) — 104% of the median of everything we compared |
| Easy to stay | ★★★★★ | Meals in a private room, Wi-Fi throughout, check-in and check-out outside the usual hours, and ten parking spaces. |
| Trust | ★★★★★ | 4.78 across 628 reviews (Rakuten Travel 628) |
| Only here | ★★★★☆ | A nine-room inn with 628 Rakuten reviews, the most of the seven we compared, averaging 4.78. |
Every booking gets a timed private bath
Yudanaka Onsen Yamazakiya Ryokan
Reviews: Rakuten Travel 4.70/5 (305) · Agoda 9.6/10 (23) · 328 in total
- Ski rental and a ski drying room
- Free shogi and go sets
- Last check-in 18:00
Why it made the five
- Every booking gets the baths to itself in a time slot.
- Rakuten’s 305 reviews average 4.7.
- Rakuten’s bath score is 4.67.
Getting there: About six minutes by bus or taxi from Yudanaka station, with a shuttle listed. About 20 minutes by car from Shinshu-Nakano IC.
Language and payment: Rakuten lists no language support. Visa, Mastercard, JCB, American Express and other cards are listed. Tattoo rules are not published, so ask when you book.
-
Right for: Two people who want to bathe without sharing with other guests.
-
Not for: Not for anyone who wants to bathe whenever they like.
-
Worth knowing: A ¥770 heating charge applies from early November to late March. Bathing tax of ¥150 and Nagano accommodation tax of ¥200 per person are extra.
Score breakdown — 77/100
| Criterion | Stars | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Quality | ★★★☆☆ | Room, bath and dinner average 4.64 on Rakuten Travel |
| Value for money | ★★★★☆ | ¥14,000 per person on a weeknight (Rakuten, dinner and breakfast) — 87% of the median of everything we compared |
| Easy to stay | ★★★★★ | A shuttle, meals in the room or a dining room, about six minutes by bus or taxi from Yudanaka station, timed private baths on every booking, and ten free parking spaces. |
| Trust | ★★★★☆ | 4.7 across 305 reviews (Rakuten Travel 305) |
| Only here | ★★★★☆ | A seven-room inn where every booking gets a timed private bath. |
Five rooms, the top food scores of the seven
Reviews: Rakuten Travel 4.85/5 (85)
- About 10 minutes by car from Yudanaka station
- Free morning coffee and a goodnight chocolate
- Five free parking spaces, by reservation
Why it made the five
- Rakuten’s 4.85 average is the highest of the seven.
- The private free-flowing bath is limited to three groups a day.
- Dinner and breakfast in your room or a private room.
Getting there: About 10 minutes by car from Yudanaka station, with a pick-up on request.
Language and payment: Rakuten lists no language support, though there is a writing pad for conversation at the entrance. Rakuten’s card field says cards are not accepted. Tattoo rules are not published, so ask when you book.
-
Right for: Two people going for the food, or who want to eat in the room.
-
Not for: Five rooms, and its 85 reviews are the fewest of the seven. Rakuten’s card field says cards are not accepted.
-
Worth knowing: Call if you will check in after 18:00.
Score breakdown — 75/100
| Criterion | Stars | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Quality | ★★★★☆ | Room, bath and dinner average 4.78 on Rakuten Travel |
| Value for money | ★★★☆☆ | ¥16,000 per person on a weeknight (Rakuten, dinner and breakfast) — 100% of the median of everything we compared |
| Easy to stay | ★★★★★ | A pick-up from Yudanaka station on request, meals in your room or a private room, a free-flowing private bath limited to three groups a day, last check-in at 22:00, and a writing pad and shower chair for guests who need them. |
| Trust | ★★★★☆ | 4.85 across 85 reviews (Rakuten Travel 85) |
| Only here | ★★★★☆ | Rakuten’s dinner and breakfast scores are both 5.00, the highest of the seven we compared, with a private bath limited to three groups a day. |
Eight rooms, known for its Shinshu beef steak plan
Reviews: Rakuten Travel 4.64/5 (415) · Agoda 9.4/10 (24) · 439 in total
- A three-storey wooden inn
- Free morning coffee and green tea in the room
- Parking is a shared lot about 100 metres away
Why it made the five
- A popular steak plan of apple-fed Shinshu beef.
- Rakuten’s 415 reviews average 4.64, with dinner at 4.79.
- A large bath on a free-flowing hot spring.
Getting there: About five minutes by bus from Yudanaka station. Pick-up possible for two or more on a two-meal plan, if arranged in advance.
Language and payment: Rakuten lists a few staff with a little English. Rakuten’s card field says cards are not accepted. Tattoo rules are not published, so ask when you book.
-
Right for: Two people going for a beef dinner.
-
Not for: Its weekday low is the highest of the seven, and Rakuten’s card field says cards are not accepted.
-
Worth knowing: As an Andai Onsen inn, its guests cannot use Shibu’s public baths. Check in by 19:00 on a dinner plan. The private bath is for early check-in guests only.
Score breakdown — 63/100
| Criterion | Stars | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Quality | ★★★☆☆ | Room, bath and dinner average 4.59 on Rakuten Travel |
| Value for money | ★★☆☆☆ | ¥18,000 per person on a weeknight (Rakuten, dinner and breakfast) — 117% of the median of everything we compared |
| Easy to stay | ★★★★★ | A pick-up for two or more on a two-meal plan, dinner in the room or a private room, five minutes by bus from Yudanaka station, last check-in at 23:00, and a few staff with a little English. |
| Trust | ★★★★☆ | 4.64 across 415 reviews (Rakuten Travel 415) |
| Only here | ★★★★☆ | A three-storey wooden inn of eight rooms with a popular steak plan of apple-fed Shinshu beef, and a 4.79 dinner score on Rakuten. |
Know before you book
- Yudanaka station is the end of the Nagano Electric Railway. All five inns give it as their nearest station, and the bus takes 5 to 10 minutes to most of them.
- These are small inns of five to nine rooms, so cheap dates go quickly. We found few open dates for several of them.
- Whether you can use Shibu’s public baths depends on the inn. Andaikan’s listing says its guests cannot, so check before you book.
- Nagano’s accommodation tax has applied since 1 June 2026, and bathing tax is extra too. Pay both on top of the rate.
- Yamazakiya adds a ¥770 heating charge from early November to late March.
- For the Jigokudani snow monkeys, note that the road to the car park can close in winter.
How we chose: theme, conditions, scoring
How we chose
- Candidates: every property in Yudanaka and Shibu listed on Rakuten Travel — 101
- Passed the review filter (counts and averages on Rakuten Travel, the one site that lists every property in the area): 41
- Met every condition below: 10
- Kept: five, each the best at something different
Where the facts come from
- Facts: Rakuten Travel property information (in some articles, each hotel’s own site too)
- Prices: Rakuten Travel live availability, Wednesdays and Saturdays over eight weeks
- Reviews: the count and average on Rakuten Travel, as given in each hotel’s Trust row. Agoda’s reviews are shown under each hotel name for reference only and do not count towards the score
Conditions (all of them, not most of them)
- A Rakuten Travel plan with dinner and breakfast where two people in one room come to ¥40,000 or less, tax included but bathing and accommodation tax extra — prices as of November 2026, on the cheapest date we found. Weekends and holidays cost more
- A hot spring on site, communal or private
- Reviews are consistent: a floor of 30 or more reviews averaging 4.2 on Rakuten Travel
- In the Yudanaka and Shibu hot spring towns: inns up in Shiga Kogen are left out
- For comparison, Rakuten must publish room and bath scores, and any Saturday we found must also stay within ¥40,000 for two
Scoring
Five criteria, one to five stars each, weighted to one hundred points. Every star says where the number came from.
- Quality25 pts
- The average of the room, bath and dinner scores on Rakuten Travel.
- Value for money35 pts
- The cheapest two-meal plan per person against the median of the inns we compared.
- Easy to stay10 pts
- A free pick-up, dinner in the room or a private room, and practical extras such as private baths, parking and language support.
- Trust25 pts
- Review counts and averages published by Rakuten Travel.
- Only here5 pts
- What this inn has that the other 6 we compared do not, at this price.
What we dropped
| Property | Verdict | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Shibu Shiroganeya Ryokan | Runner-up (54/100) | Scored 54: a good price, but the lowest room, bath and dinner average of the seven at 4.16, and a 4.24 review average. |
| Shibu Onsen Taiyokan Yamatoya | Runner-up (52/100) | Scored 52: its weekday low is 110% of the median, and its review scores do not make up for that. |
| Shibu Onsen Shunran no Yado Sakaeya | Over budget | Rakuten’s 1,275 reviews average 4.85, but the cheapest two-meal plan is over ¥40,000 for two. |
| Yudanaka Onsen Biyu no Yado | Passed over | A weekday fits, but the cheapest Saturday we found is over ¥40,000 for two. |
| Shibu Onsen Shin-eikan | Passed over | Price and reviews fit, but Rakuten shows no room or bath score, so it could not be compared on the same terms. |
| Club Wyndham Shirakabaso Shiga Kogen | Passed over | Meets the price and review conditions, but it is up in Shiga Kogen, not in the Yudanaka and Shibu hot spring towns. |
| Shibu Onsen Kaneki Hotel | Below the floor | Rakuten’s 395 reviews average 3.65, below our 4.2 floor. |
Questions visitors ask
Which inn works best without a car?
Andaikan is about five minutes by bus from Yudanaka station, with a pick-up for two or more on a two-meal plan if arranged in advance. Yamazakiya is about six minutes by bus or taxi, Masaki Ryokan about ten by bus, and Fujiya offers a pick-up on request. Rakuten gives only driving directions for Tamakyu, so ask before you book.
Which inns let us bathe without other guests?
Yamazakiya gives every booking a timed private bath. Fujiya has a free-flowing private bath for three groups a day, and Masaki Ryokan’s bath is a family bath. At Andaikan the private bath is for early check-in guests only.
Can we eat in our room?
Masaki Ryokan and Fujiya serve both meals in the room or a private room, and Yamazakiya in the room or a dining room. Andaikan lists the room or a private room for dinner. Tamakyu uses a private room or hall.
Can we use Shibu’s public baths?
It depends on the inn. Andaikan’s listing says its guests cannot, because it is an Andai Onsen inn. For the others, Rakuten does not say, so ask when you book.
Can we pay by card?
Masaki Ryokan, Tamakyu and Yamazakiya list cards. Rakuten’s card field for Fujiya and Andaikan says cards are not accepted, so carry cash. Taxes on top of the rate may also be paid on site.
Changes
- 2026-11-07 First published. Scored from 101 candidates.